Collecting data is not the same as having evidence.
Many organisations have spreadsheets, surveys, attendance lists and case studies. But when an auditor, funder or certification body reviews their monitoring, evaluation and learning system, they are not only asking whether data exists.
They are asking whether the system is credible, consistent and useful.
Data versus evidence
Data is what you collect: attendance numbers, survey responses, beneficiary records, emissions figures, training completions or case studies.
Evidence is data placed in context, collected consistently, quality-checked and connected to a claim.
For example, “300 people attended our training” is data.
“300 people attended, 87% completed the programme, and 74% reported applying at least one new practice within three months” moves closer to evidence.
The difference matters because decisions and claims should rest on evidence, not activity counts alone.
What reviewers look for
1. A clear purpose
Auditors want to know why the MEL system exists.
What decisions is it meant to support? Who uses the information? What questions does it answer?
A system built only to complete a report is harder to defend than one designed to help a team learn and improve.
2. A logical results chain
Reviewers check whether there is a credible link between what you do and the change you claim.
They look for:
- Clear activities
- Defined outputs
- Plausible outcomes
- A stated theory of change or results framework
- Assumptions and risks
If your activities and claimed impact are disconnected, no amount of data will fully solve the problem.
3. Relevant indicators
Auditors check whether indicators measure what matters.
Common issues include:
- Too many indicators
- Indicators that measure activity rather than change
- Metrics chosen because they are easy, not meaningful
- No baseline or target
- Indicators that do not connect to the theory of change
A small set of relevant indicators is usually stronger than a long list nobody can maintain.
4. Consistent data collection
It is not enough to collect data once. Reviewers look for consistency over time.
They may ask:
- Who collects the data?
- When is it collected?
- What tool or template is used?
- How are definitions applied?
- How are missing responses handled?
- How often is the data reviewed?
If every team collects data differently, comparisons become unreliable.
5. Data quality checks
Auditors look for evidence that data has been checked before being used.
This can include:
- Checking for missing or duplicate entries
- Reviewing outliers
- Confirming calculations
- Documenting assumptions
- Comparing data across sources
- Explaining changes in definitions or methodology
You do not need a perfect system. You need to show that you take quality seriously.
6. Ethical and responsible data practices
Especially when working with people, reviewers pay attention to consent, privacy and safeguarding.
They may check whether you:
- Explain why data is collected
- Obtain appropriate consent
- Protect personal information
- Limit access to sensitive data
- Avoid collecting unnecessary personal details
- Use feedback ethically and safely
Good data practice is part of good impact practice.
7. Evidence of use
One of the most important questions is simple: What did you do with the information?
Reviewers look for signs that data informs decisions, such as:
- Meeting notes where results were discussed
- Programme adjustments based on findings
- Learning summaries
- Updated plans or targets
- Decisions to scale, adapt or stop an activity
An MEL system that produces reports but no learning is incomplete.
8. Documentation and traceability
Finally, reviewers check whether someone else could follow your process.
Can they see where a number came from? Can they understand how a conclusion was reached? Can they identify who was responsible for each step?
Clear documentation turns internal knowledge into evidence that holds up.
The practical test
Before an audit, ask your team:
- Can we explain where this number came from?
- Can we show how it was collected?
- Can we explain what it does and does not tell us?
- Can we show how we used it?
If you can answer those questions, your MEL system is likely in much better shape than you think.
At Proof of Change, we help teams turn scattered data into MEL systems that are practical, credible and ready for scrutiny.
Want an honest review of your current MEL system? Get in touch.
